Amy Poehler and Mike Schur are back together, but the early reviews for their new Peacock comedy Dig are split. All 10 episodes of the half-hour series premiere Monday, November 23, on Peacock, and critics agree the show is likable — they disagree on whether it is funny enough.
Dig is based on Kate Myers’ 2023 novel Excavations and follows four women at an archaeological dig in coastal Greece who uncover a rare artifact, only to watch it go missing. Poehler plays Elise, the weary second-in-command at the site, opposite Hugh Laurie as renowned archaeologist Neville Wycombe. Fina Strazza, Geraldine Viswanathan and Antonia Thomas round out the central four as the workplace comedy turns into a full mystery.
The Hollywood Reporter’s Daniel Fienberg is the most measured, calling the series likable but underwhelming and a minor disappointment. He praises the cast as too good to dislike, singles out Strazza as the show’s standout, and calls Poehler an entirely appealing straight woman and Laurie at his funniest as the bloviating Neville. But he finds the pilot clunky and exposition-heavy, the mystery superficial, and the show never quite finding its next gear.
The A.V. Club lands in similar territory, calling Dig gentler and more grounded than Parks and Recreation, and not nearly as laugh-out-loud funny. Its review says the series gets off to a rough, unfunny start before finding its momentum and becoming the wholesome, quirky comedy it wants to be, balancing light humour with loneliness, outsider status and female friendship.
The warmer notices come from Awards Buzz, which gives the season 8/10 and calls it an entertaining and accessible workplace comedy with a top-tier cast that gradually builds tension and deepens its mystery, and from Big Gold Belt, which calls it the laugh a lot of viewers need right now and praises a cast in which every woman gets a real arc. The split leaves Dig a slow-burn watch: a gentle ensemble comedy critics say improves once the artifact theft kicks the story into gear.
More from XGViral: critics were also split on this week’s other big opener — our Sunrise on the Reaping review roundup. Think you can name a movie from a single frame? Play Title Card.
via The Hollywood Reporter — roundup also draws on published reviews from The A.V. Club, Awards Buzz and Big Gold Belt



















