Amy Poehler and Mike Schur’s new Peacock comedy Dig arrives Monday, November 23, with all 10 episodes dropping at once — and the first reviews are split down the middle. The series reunites the Parks and Recreation duo, with J.J. Philbin co-creating, and adapts Kate Myers’ 2023 novel Excavations into a half-hour comedy about archaeologists on a summer dig in Greece.
Poehler stars as Elise DeBellnick, a career archaeologist serving as second-in-command to Hugh Laurie’s pompous, almost-always-about-to-retire professor Dr. Neville Wycombe. When Elise and three colleagues uncover a rare artifact that then goes missing, the show pivots from workplace comedy into a season-long mystery about what they found — and whether to keep it secret.
The Hollywood Reporter calls Dig “likable but underwhelming,” summing it up as “a pleasantly likable comedy, but it’s never hugely funny” — a minor disappointment from a cast too good to dislike, but a show that never finds the next gear, “be it zaniness or sentiment.” Its bottom line: “Can you dig it? Sure, though maybe not a lot.”
TVLine is colder, grading the show a C+ and calling it “a disappointingly flat comedy with a muddled tone,” arguing the premise “doesn’t translate into many laughs” and the season-long mystery “never becomes all that compelling.” The A.V. Club lands in the middle, finding a “cozy” comedy with a rough, unfunny start that “eventually finds the momentum to become the wholesome, quirky comedy it wants to be.”
The most enthusiastic take comes from Collider, which calls Dig Poehler’s best TV role in years and urges viewers to “stick with it” — the early episodes strain as a workplace comedy, but the show finds itself once the team stops bickering over the chain of command and starts solving the mystery together. AwardsBuzz agrees, scoring it 8/10 as an “entertaining and accessible workplace comedy.”
The one point of near-consensus: Fina Strazza, who plays wide-eyed student Patty, is the breakout. Collider says her performance “should have casting directors rearranging their call sheets,” and TVLine credits her fumbling sincerity with providing most of the show’s comedy. Think you can guess which new shows critics will love next? Play Title Card and test your TV instincts. We rounded up the critics on the Hunger Games prequel earlier this week — read our Sunrise on the Reaping review roundup — and Nicolas Cage’s latest got a similarly mixed reception in our Best Pancakes in the County roundup.
Source: via The Hollywood Reporter — https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-reviews/dig-review-amy-poehler-mike-schur-hugh-laurie-peacock-1236758949/



















